Cornwall Insight: evaluating drivers of low-carbon investment in a subsidy free world event

On 17 October 2018 Cornwall Insight hosted a successful and well attended event where the future of support for renewable power generation, against the backdrop of the significant gap between current deployment levels and what must be delivered to meet decarbonisation goals, was discussed.

Cornwall Insight experts discussed how although  wholesale prices are currently high, the power price “captured” by wind and solar projects is set to fall over the next decade due to the “cannibalisation effect” owing to the continued deployment of intermittent generation. This means in effect that as more and more renewables are deployed, the wholesale price itself is pushed down. This creates an environment where it is extremely hard for investors to back renewables solely on the basis of future wholesale power prices.  

This is presents real problems for investors, not least as National Grid predicts that to meet a pathway that sees climate change limited to 2°C, 129GW of renewables will have to be in operation by 2050. Currently 39GW of renewables are deployed in GB, with many of the earliest projects coming to the end of their lifespans and in need of repowering.

Also debated were the merits of proffered solutions such as Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs) and renewables winning contracts under the Capacity Market. Some PPAs offer floor prices, but they are typically less than £20/MWh – far below the level needed to make them viable on their own. A market-led alternative to provide long-term price stability is a corporate PPA, whereby there is a contract between a creditworthy major energy user and a renewables developer. Whilst this is a popular route to market in other jurisdictions, including the US and parts of Europe, there are complexities for widescale adoption of these contracts in GB and our experts do not believe they will pull through sufficient investment in new renewables projects.  

Wind and solar may be able to offer services to National Grid in future, through the Capacity Market and balancing services, but this will not provide enough stability for investors and under current rules they face a prohibitively low “de-rating factor” – essentially a measure of the forecasted availability of an installation in the case of a potential system stress event.

We presented our preferred solution to help call forward investment in new renewables: a policy intervention through a floor price Contract for Difference (CfD) mechanism. Under a floor price CfD, contracts would be auctioned in the same fashion as today, but applicants would bid in the floor price, rather than the fixed price payment they require to make the project investable. If wholesale power prices fall below the floor price, then levy-funded payments would be made to the recipient up to the floor. Where wholesale power prices rise above the floor again, the recipient would not receive the positive difference until they had paid back floor payments received. The benefit of this approach is that it is not a subsidy, but instead supports investment at no extra cost to consumers over the long-run, keeps the costs of renewables falling overall, and will see competitively-priced projects will continue to come through to help meet 2050 emissions targets.  

SLIDES FROM TODAY’S EVENT CAN BE DOWNLOADED HERE

Related thinking

Uncategorised

More details required for large-scale solar rollout in EU

Last week, our 'Financing net zero forum' gathered to discuss the role of private capital for the next wave of solar across Europe. Joining the meeting chair, Cornwall Insight's Daniel Atzori, were our guest panellists from a leading developer and the Global Infrastructure Investor Association (GIIA). With the European Commission...

Low carbon generation

Our Renewables Pipeline Tracker: In with the new – scoping projects and progression through planning stages

Our latest Renewables Pipeline Tracker was published on 11 June, and this blog provides a summary of some of the recent developments in our coverage of the pipeline for new build and repowering renewables assets in GB. What’s new? Seabed leasing rounds, scoping projects and CfD announcements Since our previous...

Commercial and market outlook

Data centres predicted to become prosumers of electricity

In combination with Cornwall Insight and Bit Power, Host in Ireland published its Biannual report of Ireland’s Data Hosting Industry. The report highlights the importance of sustainability in Ireland’s digital transformation. The report confirmed the number of operational data centres in Ireland increased by 25 per cent over the past...

Low carbon generation

Investor optimism sparks PPA competition

In recent months, Cornwall Insight has issued several of our regular subscription reports from our PPA Insights Service covering both renewable and flexibility Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) markets, namely the Green Power Forecast, Renewable PPA Market Share and Flexible PPA Market reports. As part of these reports, we conduct surveys...

Regulation and policy

Electricity transmission charging reform – overtaken by changing priorities?

Charging for the transmission network is never out of the development process for long. From major reviews, such as that initiated under Project Transmit in 2010, to significant reforms such as removing the triad benefit from distributed generation in 2018, and a host of smaller developments, change seems the only...

Commercial and market outlook

In the midst of the Australian Energy Transformation Process

Australia is in the midst of an energy supply and distribution transformation. This transition is twofold and includes not just bridging the gap from conventional fossil fuels to renewable technologies (due to their reduced carbon footprint, lower levelized cost of energy and improved reliability levels by comparation), but also requires...

Low carbon generation

Nuclear energy and its potential importance for net zero

This article was originally written as a longer piece in Energy Spectrum on 21 March 2021. To find out more about a subscription to Energy Spectrum, please contact Nick on n.palmer@cornwall-insight.com. Nuclear energy has been an integral part of the UK’s electricity system for many decades. Currently, nuclear provides around...

Announcement

GB consultancy: Our 2020 highlights

We are independent commercial advisors to over 300 energy companies from generators, project developers, energy suppliers, network companies, investors, government departments and professional firms. Our team has over 40 years of energy market experience and works across the whole energy chain. Here is a small selection of our work in...