ESB charts direction for changes to the NEM

The below extract has been taken from our eighth edition of ‘Energy Spectrum Australia’, and if you would like to read more about the latest developments in the Australian energy market, please contact for a free trial of our ‘Energy Spectrum Australia’ service.

The Council of Australian Governments (COAG) has provided an update on its post-2025 market design project in an Energy Security Board (ESB) Directions Paper, published in April.

Work on the development of a long-term market framework to support reliability started in March 2019 when the Energy Council requested the ESB to advise on this issue. In November 2019, the Council sought recommendations from the ESB for discussion at its March 2020 meeting. These recommendations have since been integrated into the strategic approach for the post-2025 market design programme.

Phases of programme development and delivery are broken down into short-term, intermediate and longer-term deliverables. Final recommendations on all aspects of the deliverables will be made no later than mid-2021. The development of legislation and rules packages will then follow.
There are seven core market design initiatives being progressed in the post-2025 programme:

  • Investment signals for reliability – evaluating the case for introduction of capacity mechanisms.
  • Aging Thermal Generator Strategy – market arrangements and regulatory approaches to ensure that sufficient replacement capacity is available to replace aging thermal generators.
  • Essential System Services – an enduring regulatory framework that will enable the market operator and participants to meet future system services needs.
  • Ahead Markets – options ranging from smaller changes to strengthen the commitment mechanism for reliability and security, to more extensive changes like cross-market coordination with gas.
  • Two-sided Markets – a model that promotes direct interaction between suppliers and customers, encouraging price responsiveness and demand flexibility. Final recommendations on a market design will be made to Energy Council by the end of this year.
  • Distributed Energy Resource Markets (the scope for this programme is currently being developed).
  • Coordination of Generation and Transmission Investment – to address the challenge of integrating variable renewable energy into the electricity system.

Each of the initiatives will be assessed via a “balanced scorecard” approach, which assesses how each achieves the post-2025 programme vision and objectives. The objectives will build on the strategic priorities identified by the ESB in its Strategic Energy Plan.
A post-2025 programme consultation is planned for August 2020 and market design options are expected to be developed for consultation by end of this year. Recommendations on market design will be provided to the Energy Council in mid-2021. The ESB says it will continue to support the development and delivery of initial design options.

The scope of the post-2025 programme is extensive and will fundamentally alter the operation of the NEM.

Ageing generators and investment: while it is not specifically mentioned (possibly due to negative connotations) a ‘capacity market’ is likely to be one of the main options considered to provide confidence for asset replacement. Any evaluation of future capacity has the unenviable job of reviewing the evolving generation and consumption dynamics which by 2030 will be completely different (even if that is just due to demand response participation and EVs).

Ahead Markets: It appears to have already been decided that an ahead-market mechanism will form part of any new market design as the ESB has already outlined that it believes the current dispatch mechanism is no longer sufficient to maintain system security. It only remains for the most beneficial option to be identified.

CoGaTi: Under the program overview the ESB is projected to have draft rules for CoGaTi by the end of 2020, suggesting that the outcomes of the AEMC’s modelling cost and benefits are already a foregone conclusion and that CoGaTi will be progressed in some shape or form.

The DER workstream should also be watched closely as the impact of new markets in this area will flow through to the rest of the wholesale mechanisms. The AER is currently looking into DER valuation mechanisms.

Related thinking

Commercial and market outlook

Evaluating the benefits of local coordination mechanisms in power supply

In March, Cornwall Insight launched its new Energy Spectrum Europe publication in collaboration with the Institute of Energy Economics at the University of Cologne (EWI). Below is an extract of our Energy Perspective article from our latest issue, written by Konstantin Gruber and Nils Namockel from EWI. Local forms of coordination are...

Commercial and market outlook

AEMO: new markets & standards to help integrate renewables

The below sample has been taken from our second edition of Energy Spectrum Australia, and if you have enjoyed reading this article and want to read more about the latest developments in the Australian energy market, please contact Ben Hall,,  for more information. On 1 October AEMO published an...

E-mobility and low carbon

ESB charge points: Mo money mo problems

ESB announced this week that charging your car at its public fast charge points will now be a paid-for service. Although the fee for fast charging has always been anticipated, the timing is interesting considering the government’s intention to have 1mn EVs on the road by 2030 and the historically...

Commercial and market outlook

Editor’s Pick | Is ESB’s market dominance still a concern?

The Electricity Supply Board (ESB). It doesn’t take too long venturing into the Irish energy sector before one encounters this company. Founded in 1927, the former monopoly provider was responsible for rural electrification in 1946. ESB group companies own the network and participate in generation and supply markets. In the...

Home supply and services

We built this city: new registrations, a segment emerges

Valentine’s Day saw the publication of the Irish quarterly retail market report by the Commission for Regulation of Utilities (CRU), which noted 11 price increases over the course of 2018. It is an opportune time to consider a potential source of future competition: new residential dwellings. This week’s blog looks...

Low carbon generation

When the Wild Wind Blows… time for offshore wind?

On 22 January 2019, an announcement was made that ESB and Parkwind, which has been developing the Oriel Offshore Wind project off the coast of Louth, have entered into a partnership for the Oriel project, as well as ESB’s Clogherhead project. This has been a welcome announcement in light of...

Low carbon generation

Invisible Touch: Irish energy and the EIB

Last week, ESB and Bord na Móna announced financial close on the 89MW Oweninny wind farm in Mayo. One interesting feature of the public statement was that the European Investment Bank (EIB) was providing 50% of the estimated €160mn investment. As discussed below, in recent years the EIB has not...