Let markets run or regulate to accelerate: a false choice or key net zero decision?

Earlier this week Cornwall Insight convened a group of industry leaders from across the energy and investment space to discuss business preparedness for net zero, and what more can be done to unlock capital to make net zero a reality. The session, hosted by our non-executive chairman Volker Beckers, is part of a series of events we have been running since 2019. We have been engaging regularly with key actors in the energy transition, convening insights that contribute positively to key parts of the net zero journey.

The first part of our discussion yesterday focused on the elevation of net zero to the board rooms of all businesses as it becomes a key factor in capital raising, social value and talent attraction. The good news is that this will provide an expanded corporate impetus to the mission to decarbonise across business and industry. But, the group noted limitations in the short term as businesses get distracted by the challenge of the pandemic, and also anxiety about how to get to achieve very public corporate level targets.

There was a general recognition that consumers will have a key role to play. Most recognised the benefit of government setting unequivocal targets to accelerate changing social norms, but then to step back and let businesses deliver. However, the group discussed how the pull from customer demand will be different in different areas. For example, in e-mobility the combination of demand emerging for electric vehicles as a positive social choice, combined with an ambitious target for phasing out combustion engines at a government level, is already creating big consumer pull. Contrast this to domestic heat where levels of consumer knowledge on what constitutes a low carbon solution, even if there is desire to adopt sustainable heating solutions, leaves a big role for different businesses to play in consumer education, and government in making the big directional calls and then creating appropriate and supporting market incentives.

The second part of our meeting discussed how to unlock capital. Interestingly, the group quickly moved beyond the typical discussion on big renewable assets – where it was recognised there is a proliferation of funds chasing mature, and big projects – to discussing how newer, decentralised consumer focussed business models might be funded.  It is clear from our discussion that innovative businesses, backed up by private capital, are already stimulating the take up of low carbon solutions in the B2C and B2B world. But the point was made that the usual adoption curve may take years to climb to levels where the costs of solutions for heat, energy efficiency and the demand side generally reduce to levels where wide-scale take-up can be achieved – particularly where consumers either lack the means or knowledge to drive faster adoption themselves. Meanwhile, the clock on net zero is already ticking loudly. Of course, one silver lining from the pandemic could be the general accelerated learning curve of digital solutions across the entire economy. But, unless this “crisis” momentum can be harnessed as we move into calmer times, then it is unclear if this high pace of innovation is sustainable, particularly against the backdrop of possible economic headwinds.

More generally, the question for government is whether there is time to allow organic consumer change to run its course? And, if they consider there is a need to accelerate, how do they strike the right balance between necessary new stimulus, without stifling welcome innovation? In other words, what balance do they strike between market signals, and regulatory compulsion without getting trapped in between? If we look at recent history of energy supplier regulation it is very unclear which philosophy will win out. This is a question we will be returning to in a future roundtable, with the aspiration of feeding views into the very dynamic policymaking process unleashed by last year’s Energy White Paper.

Related thinking


Energy market and net zero transition learning and development: Role-relevant career development training

We’re well over halfway through the calendar year and are now beginning to see more of the government’s thinking and policy-shaping around what needs to change to meet the 2050 net zero target. For example, the flurry of documents issued towards the end of 2020, including the Energy White Paper...

Net zero corporates and ESG

Data critical for sustainable investments

On 24 June, attendees to our 'Financing net zero forum' tuned in to hear the expert panel discussions on the role of data in sustainable investment. Joining the meeting chairs, Cornwall Insight's Daniel Atzori and Emma Bill were our guest panellists from Mercatus and Victory Hill Capital Group LLP. For investors to make...

Heat networks

Reallocating electricity policy costs to incentivise low carbon heating technologies

Funding the cost of decarbonising the power system has mainly been through the consumers' electricity bills. In fact, in 2020-21 these costs amounted to a whopping £10bn. But is this method of raising revenue for decarbonisation still fit for purpose when faced with the need to decarbonise the nation's heat?...

Net zero corporates and ESG

Financing net zero panel advises policymakers for a long-term view of net zero to boost merchant renewable confidence

Last Thursday's 'Financing net zero forum' brought together 580 registered attendees across the renewables sector to listen to the expert panel discuss managing renewable merchant risk. Joining the chair of the meeting were experts from across the industry, with Shoosmiths sponsoring the afternoon discussions. Merchant renewables – the development of...

Net zero corporates and ESG

Get ready for climate risk reporting?

On 30 April we released the latest copy of our Energy net zero. The publication takes an in-depth look at the UK's transition to a low carbon economy. The below is an extract from our Energy Perspective on Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosure (TCFD). The article was originally published in the...

Low carbon generation

Data centres predicted to become prosumers of electricity

In combination with Cornwall Insight and Bit Power, Host in Ireland published its Biannual report of Ireland’s Data Hosting Industry. The report highlights the importance of sustainability in Ireland’s digital transformation. The report confirmed the number of operational data centres in Ireland increased by 25 per cent over the past...

Regulation and policy

Why energy system governance is not fit for purpose

In my recent blog, the Emperor’s new clothes I referenced a poll of our Financing Net Zero (FNZ) membership which revealed 75% support for an energy systems architect to ensure we manage the net zero transition. In the spirit of independent thinking that Cornwall Insight is known for, I respectfully disagreed and...

Low carbon generation

How nuclear energy can help the UK reach its net zero goals

This article was originally written in Energy Spectrum on 21 March 2021. To find out more about a subscription to Energy Spectrum, please contact Nick on n.palmer@cornwall-insight.com. There are several challenges to reaching net zero, where its proponents believe nuclear could add value. Some of tomorrow’s main issues concern: How to provide low...