Australian Chart of the week | A little respect (just a little bit): FCAS costs hit solar hardest

Wholesale energy prices may have hit some of their lowest prices in years, but the total cost of Frequency Control Ancillary Services (FCAS) skyrocketed in Q1 resulting from the South Australian Islanding event. The islanding event threw back into the spotlight the importance of understanding the costs associated with FCAS causer pays. This Chart of the Week takes a look at how causer pays factors have changed for technologies over the past couple of years.

The SA islanding event saw the emergence of new market behaviours whereby some generators reduced their output to zero to avoid the risk of being hit with significant costs resulting from ‘causer pays’. (Quick recap – A causer pays factor is based on how much a generator deviates from their linear ramp rate to meet their next dispatch targets for each dispatch period). While renewable energy generators have historically turned off to avoid negative pricing, a new operational consideration for renewables is the liability that high regulation FCAS prices pose to the profitability of current and future renewable energy projects.

To keep reading, please log in to your account

Alternatively, please sign up to receive free market insight online and direct to your inbox

Related thinking

Low carbon generation

Australian Chart of the week | VRE pays more as PFR helps reduce coal FCAS costs

In our previous ‘Chart of the week’ in November 2020, we reviewed the increasing percentage of causer pays cost that solar generators bear due to their generation profiles and how this results in them paying significantly more of the causer pays cost as a ratio of the generation they provide. More than...

Regulation and policy

Australian Chart of the week | Peak raise regulation FCAS volumes drop by 72MWs

It is helpful to understand Frequency Control Ancillary Services (FCAS) as FCAS price forecasts are needed to estimate generator and customer costs, as well as possible revenues for new and existing ancillary service providers. AEMO procures regulation FCAS to balance frequency during normal operation. From May 2019, AEMO has procured...

Low carbon generation

Australian Chart of the week | “I feel the earth move under my feet”: from high to lows

We have seen a dramatic shift in FCAS price fortunes over the past year or so, going from all-time highs of ~$229.3mn in Q1 of 2020 (due to the separation event) to only ~$40.1mn in Q1 2021. Since 2019 we have also seen regulation raise prices decline from robust prices...

Energy storage and flexibility

Australian Chart of the week | Round and Round the Market: Black Coal vs Batteries

This year appears to be the year of the battery, with the volume of projects that have been announced or in some stage of planning approaching the 10GW mark it is worth taking a look at how batteries are performing in the FCAS markets over the last two years. Currently...

Energy storage and flexibility

Australian Chart of the week | Show me the future: can storage bank on FCAS being bankable?

Previously we have examined the importance in FCAS prices for the revenue stream for batteries. With a growing interest in batteries in the market, this ‘Chart of the week’ takes a deeper look into the impact of bidding behaviour on the Regulation Raise price since 2012. From January 2012 until...

Power and gas networks

Australian Chart of the week | Green hydrogen costs plummet, LNG prices soar

The ACCC currently calculates the LNG netback price as the price a gas exporter could receive for gas exports excluding the costs to convert and ship the gas. Asian cold weather and supply bottlenecks have driven the February LNG netback price to nearly $20 a gigajoule, more than double the...

Energy storage and flexibility

Australian Chart of the week | Yesterday, [battery storage] was such an easy game to play

FCAS continues to drive the majority of revenues for battery storage in the NEM (there are five active utility-scale battery storage projects operating in the NEM; three in SA and two in VIC), however given the forecast pipeline of prospective storage projects (with two 500MW+ projects having already been announced...

Low carbon generation

Australian Chart of the week | One of these things is not like the others: FCAS separation value

Energy storage has been at the forefront of conversations resulting from AEMO’s newly released 2020 Integrated System Plan (ISP). The ISP states that 6-19GW of dispatchable resources are needed to support more than 26GW of new renewables. So where will battery energy storage fit in and where will they make...