Who pays for supporting the net zero transition

The costs of decarbonising the power system have mainly been funded through consumers’ electricity bills. In 2020-21 these costs amounted to £10bn with the expectation that support for low carbon generation will continue to be necessary. If we are to maintain a trajectory to net zero carbon emissions at 2050, our attention will need to turn to decarbonising the nation’s heat. For most consumers, that will mean switching away from heating their homes with gas to an alternative low carbon source with costs incurred in replacing and upgrading equipment within the home and new infrastructure to support this transition. Policy decisions will need to be made around the scale, timing, cost and means of funding for this transition.


Cornwall Insight has published this thought paper to provide a range of options and illustrate the potential impacts of short-term reform in policy cost recovery. This specifically focuses on first moves to support significant decarbonisation of heat in domestic properties. While hydrogen remains some way off wider commercialisation, the government has targeted the installation of 600,000 heat pumps per year by 2028. Where these premises are connected to the gas grid, the decision about policy cost recovery will affect the relative economics of running technologies that utilise the two different fuel sources.


While initial attention may be focused on heating technologies deployed in new build premises and switching sources other than gas to electric, the longer-term goals will need to support consumers in making the decision to transition to low-carbon technologies. This report directly compares the fuel cost implications of three methods of reform for a representative domestic consumer.

Dan Starman, Lead Consultant, commented

In order to hit net zero, consumers must be weaned off of internal combustion engines and gas boilers. Electrified alternatives, such as electric vehicles and heat pumps, are seen as the current viable and scalable low carbon alternative to support this transition. However electricity currently sits at around four times the costs of gas per unit for households, in part due to the application of a raft of policy costs recovered from the electricity bill. This paper outlines why the government should take action to disentangle policy costs from electricity bills and support consumers in making choices aligned with the net zero transition

To keep reading, please log in to your account

Alternatively, please sign up to receive free market insight online and direct to your inbox

Related thinking

Low carbon generation

The net zero paradox – challenges of designing markets to bring forward low marginal cost resources

The scale and speed of the net zero targets require a refocus of the traditional goals of electricity market design to ensure efficient dispatch, adequate capacity and optimal investment. Electricity markets need to support the investment and dispatch to meet low carbon objectives, but the fundamental drivers of the electricity...

Energy storage and flexibility

Optimal coordination of active network management schemes with balancing services markets

WSP, Cornwall Insight and Complete Strategy are undertaking a Network Innovation Allowance (NIA) funded project on behalf of National Grid Electricity System Operator (NG ESO) and Western Power Distribution (WPD). The project is investigating the optimal coordination of Active Network Management (ANM) schemes on both the distribution and transmission networks...

E-mobility and low carbon

Leading the charge! Fleet charging – a catalyst for the EV revolution

PwC & Cornwall Insight have partnered to better understand and explain the rapidly evolving market for fleet electrification. Fleet charging has the potential to revolutionise EVs. It has the scale to accelerate the adoption of EVs across the UK, improve air quality, lower noise pollution and ultimately play a critical...

Heat networks

The future of UK heat networks – critical comparisons with European markets

The UK faces a variety of challenges in terms of tackling heat decarbonisation and implementing effective, low-risk options to serve toward meeting 2050 targets. Carbon produced from heat is the single largest contributor to overall emissions in the UK, at 37% of the total per year. Heat networks may have...

E-mobility and low carbon

Electric Vehicles: ‘Driven to Disruption’?

The electrification of road transport is rising swiftly up the policy agenda. It will have profound impacts across the electricity value chain. This paper explains and evaluates the electricity supplier offerings emerging for electric vehicles (EVs), driven largely by consumer demand, and how policy and regulatory frameworks need to adapt...

Low carbon generation

Turn up the volume: reinventing CfD auctions

We argue that changes to the CfD regime should be closely examined to address several limitations in the targets, timings and integration of the auctions with the wider energy system and market landscape: The current approach does not ensure that CfD procurement meets the UK’s decarbonisation trajectory;Investors do not have...