RESS-won: renewables on the march

Yesterday will be remembered as a good day for the Irish renewables industry, with the level of supported renewables capacity set to grow by over a quarter in the next 2-3 years.

After years of waiting, the first Renewable Energy Support Scheme auction (RESS-1) results are here (provisionally, pending appeals). Individual prices are confidential though the average published prices were: community projects – €104.15/MWh, solar – €72.92/MWh and all projects – €74.08/MWh.

The headline will be the 796MW of solar projects securing contracts. The big implication is, assuming successful delivery, Ireland could have 800MW grid-scale solar projects in the next couple of years. The solar industry lobbying has delivered.

However, the wind industry is not a loser here. While the capacity of winning projects was lower, 479MW, higher wind capacity factors mean that nearly twice the volume of onshore wind output is forecast to be supported than solar. Only a relatively small proportion (21MW) of the bidding wind projects did not secure a contract.

A big takeaway is the price level. The average prices obscure any variation in the bid prices. Having modelled Irish solar projects, it’s clear that developers placed reasonably lean bids to secure contracts. A lot of the wind projects are likely to be operating under less generous pricing than under previous Renewable Energy Feed-in-Tariff (REFIT) contracts.

The all projects category average price being higher than the pure solar average price suggests that a number of higher-priced solar projects didn’t or couldn’t win in the solar category and secured contracts in the all projects category. The price level and competition suggest there was also some canny bidding in the community pot.

The outcome of the auction will probably satisfy policy makers considering some of the wilder predictions pre-auction, though the price level is higher than recent auctions in other jurisdictions.

One driver for that may be network costs, which are not insubstantial.

Another talking point, the RESS contracts not being indexed to inflation, will have increased bid prices. It adds 20-30% more to a project’s operational costs, depending on assumed rates. Differences between similar bids could come down to bidders’ respective views on inflation levels. The freshly minted Department for Climate Action, Communication Networks and Transport may reconsider that aspect of design in future auctions.

While there is scope for participants to express dissatisfaction, within the RESS-1 process the only relevant grounds for appeal are procedural ones, and the auction appears to have been run as per the terms and conditions. The Minister has some powers to intervene; Minister Ryan’s return to the energy portfolio may involve him fielding calls from project owners. Our expectation is, however, that the Minister may wish to avoid intervening to maximise auction credibility.

The focus for many now shifts to ESB Networks delivering connections to meet the RESS delivery deadlines. Staff at the distribution company can expect to be hearing quite regularly from RESS project developers seeking updates on progress.

Related thinking

Commercial and market outlook

In the midst of the Australian Energy Transformation Process

Australia is in the midst of an energy supply and distribution transformation. This transition is twofold and includes not just bridging the gap from conventional fossil fuels to renewable technologies (due to their reduced carbon footprint, lower levelized cost of energy and improved reliability levels by comparation), but also requires...

Low carbon generation

Up north and down south – trends for generator TNUoS charging

The topic of generator Transmission Network Use of System (TNUoS) is becoming a subject of increasing interest for stakeholders as regulation, policy, and the generation mix create potential volatility for future charging trends. The significant costs posed through TNUoS are an important consideration for generators, with high variability between regions...

Low carbon generation

Ireland to fall short of existing climate targets under BaU approach

Published on 13 September, a report by the Irish Wind Energy Association (IWEA) has called for a new policy system to enable the rapid deployment of renewable electricity. The third in a series of four studies which make up the 70by30 Implementation Plan, Building Onshore Wind identifies policy changes required for Ireland to deliver the...

Low carbon generation

New policy measures needed to drive renewable generation

Published on 24 August, a new report by Energy Storage Ireland and the Irish Wind Energy Association (IWEA) called for action to strengthen Ireland’s electricity grid. The second of a series of four studies which make up the government’s 70 by 30 Implementation Plan, Saving Power outlines how to minimise dispatch down and increase the use...

Low carbon generation

All-Island wind dispatch-down rises year-on-year

On 17 September, EirGrid published its Annual Renewable Energy Constraint and Curtailment Report 2019 which sets out the amount of wind and, for the first time, solar energy, that is available but cannot be used by the system (i.e. the dispatch-down of energy). Overall, the dispatch-down of energy from wind in Ireland...

Low carbon generation

RESS-1 application closing date is further extended

With a lot of uncertainty around the impacts of COVID-19 on global supply chains and renewable project delivery we are starting to see the effects in the Irish Energy market, notably the announcement that prequalification for the Renewable Energy Support Scheme in Ireland will be extended. In December 2019, the...

E-mobility and low carbon

Off the pace: Irish EV sales lag 2030 target levels

This week’s blog compares the number of electric cars, including hybrid variants, sold in Ireland to date in 2020 against the same period for 2019. It shows that in January, EV registrations rose by 73.6% to 5,739 compared with January 2019. In February, sales rose by 13.3% compared with the...

Low carbon generation

Sail away: Offshore wind vs. RESS

Last week the European Commission proposed a “Climate Law” enshrining in legislation the objective of achieving climate neutrality by 2050. In this week’s blog, we consider the role of wind in achieving this goal, and Irelands role in the European Green Deal. As we would expect, the green deal identifies...